Video History Project

Bibliography

Expanding the History of Early Video in New York City

Abstract

Drawing on interviews made in the fall of 2015 with Barry Rebo, Anton Perich, Jaime Davidovich and Edin Velez, the paper adds to the history of New York's early-1970s Portapak era the practitioners who worked outside, or at the edge of, the founding video collectives. It follows their dealings with those groups, their funding, public access cable and broadcast television as outlets for their work, and what became of their early tapes.

PDF (27 pages) · Internet Archive

People in this text: Edin Velez, Jaime Davidovich, Anton Perich, Barry Rebo, Deirdre Boyle.

About the author: Paul Dougherty.

Introduction

This paper endeavors to add to what is known about the early 70s video scene in New York City, the original Sony Portapak era. It is beyond the scope of this project to repeat all the exposition or cite all the historical evidence about that period detailed by scholars like Deirdre Boyle in works such as her authoritative "Subject to Change: Guerrilla Television Revisited" (1997). That book and other such video histories deal largely with the handful of original video collectives. This paper is meant to augment such histories by concentrating on lesser known but important early video practitioners, those who were not connected to those groups or only loosely. This research might form the basis of a more extensive history of early New York video at a future date. Hence the scope here will limited to a handful of issues and will not draw any sweeping conclusions.

Four interviews with early video practitioners form the basis of this study. Each subject was interviewed in person for this project in the Fall of 2015: Barry Rebo and Anton Perich on November 19th, Jaime Davidovich on November 27th and Edin Velez on December 17th. Unless otherwise identified, all quotes from these individuals are from these interviews. The convention of repeating the phrase "personal communication" and the date after each quote will be dispensed with.

The term "early video" in this context is a shorthand for half-inch open reel video technology introduced by Sony in the mid to late 1960's. In the early 1970's these systems increasingly came into the hands of artists, documentarians and media activists operating in the spirit of the era's counter-culture.

In 1968 and to a greater extend in 1969, the original band of early video people came together in NYC and formed the nucleus that of the scene. Deirdre Boyle is the preeminent scholar of this era and has chronicled these core groups, she states "Underground video groups appeared throughout the United States, but New York City served as the hub of the 1960s video underground scene. Prominent early collectives included the Videofreex, People's Video Theater, Global Village, and Raindance Corporation." (1992, p.68). Raindance was the first and the other groups were effectively spin-offs. The house publication of Raindance, a self-styled, counter-cultural "think-tank" was "Radical Software" (1970-74).

It is difficult to briefly characterize these core groups and their common worldview. It was best represented in print by Radical Software. Decentralization and democratization of television and media were a central tenants, along with the notion of turning media consumers into producers. Boyle summarizes the zeitgeist this way "the cosmic vision and Utopian dreams that he (Buckminster Fuller) and other futurist philosophers offered, became the touchstone of much video writing." (1997, p.3).

The four people featured in this paper got involved in video circa 1970 and interacted with the cited foundational groups to varying degrees. Their paths to video were all different and all took diverging career paths. Besides being illustrative case studies, their trajectories and overlapping views speak to issues of (video) community, mission and preservation. There were divisions in the community and differences in agendas which are drawn out in topics such as "video as fine art" and alternatives to galleries/museums. Such alternatives raise the subject of outlets for work, namely local cable television's Public Access channels and broadcast television.

Jaime Davidovich (b. 1936) was a painter who moved to the United States from Argentina. His first experience with video came as a result of off-hour access to a studio in a operating theater at the Cleveland Clinic in Ohio. Later he was able to purchase his first portapak with a grant from the National Endowment for the Arts in 1973. Davidovich became best known as a video artist, public access producer and non-profit organizer. In these different capacities he combined a focus on minimal and conceptual art in his personal work with a populist, humorous "pop" approach to his many art television series on public access. Writing about his "Live! Show" New York Times’ television critic John J. O’Connor described him as “a persona somewhere between Bela Lugosi and Andy Kaufman. He wears a white jacket and offers his peculiar prescriptions for the future, couched in a context that borrows from the theater of the absurd" (1985). Guests on that program included artists such as Laurie Anderson, Eric Bogosian and Tony Oursler.

Anton Perich (b. 1945) is New York filmmaker, photographer, painter and video artist. He was born in Croatia and moved to the United States via Paris in 1970. That year he befriended filmmaker Michel Auder and started borrowing his portapak to make short (approximately 30 minute) video "movies" that featured members the Andy Warhol entourage. Regular cast members in these improvised videos included Taylor Mead and Candy Darling. His first installment of what would become a regular NYC public access show "Anton Perich Presents" was cablecast in 1973. It's outrageous adult content provoked censorship by Manhattan Cable Television. The show and censorship motivated a sizable article in the Village Voice (Robinson, 1973, p.33). This publicity helped garner attention for public access which then typically featured religious and community programs. In later years his program evolved to pioneer a kind of "downtown" roving reporter version of Entertainment Tonight that featured celebrities, fashion shows and nightlife. Perich is especially well known as a photographer who chronicled the Max's Kansas City demimonde.

Barry Rebo (b. 1949) is best known in a popular culture context as being Bruce Springsteen's video Boswell. First shooting him in clubs starting in 1971 and then in the recording studio when the breakthrough LP "Born To Run" was made. His footage was used extensively in "making of" documentaries about that LP and Springsteen's next. Rebo was a pioneer in using the U-Matic format as an alternative to film in making broadcast quality documentaries and entertainment programs. He was the (video) cinematographer of the 1979 Saturday Night Live spin-off movie "Mr. Mike's Mondo Video." In 1986 he started REBO Studio introducing high definition television production to the American and international filmmaking community. Currently he is Managing Director of DirectCinema (North America), Europe's leading digital cinema services organization.

Edin Velez (B. 1951) has been producing documentaries, art videos and installations since the early 1970's. Raised in Puerto Rico, he came to New York City in 1970 and immediately became part of the early video scene. His earlier works ranged from video synthesizer pieces to an "art" documentary entitled "Meta Mayan II" which he described as a poetic observation of the Guatemalan Highlands. It aired on WNET several times. He was the recipient of Guggenheim and Rockefeller Fellowships as well as the American Film Institute’s Maya Deren Award for Excellence in Film and Video. His works have been exhibited at the Whitney Biennial, Documenta 8, the Tate Gallery, the Louvre Museum and additionally found in the permanent collections of the Museum of Modern Art (New York), Stedelijk Museum (Amsterdam) and Hara Museum (Toyko). Edin Velez is currently a Professor and Coordinator of the Video Production Program at Rutgers University-Newark.

Interactions with Original Video Groups

To briefly summarize the interactions these four individuals had with New York's original video collectives; one person wanted to join a group and did so easily, another felt shut out initially, a third was happy to be working independently in an outer orbit and the last stood almost completely apart from the rest of the early video scene.

Along with a utopian bent, the early video groups had a collectivist aspect that was in sync with the communal leanings of that era's counter-culture. (VideoFreex did become a commune in Lanesville NY.) The utopian and collectivist spirit imply an open, egalitarian ethos, so it's no wonder that newcomer Barry Rebo thought he might enter their ranks. After all, these were not formal companies that required job applications.

Earlier Rebo had been accepted to the graduate film school at Stanford University, but in his 1970 first semester, there was a surprise turn of events. "I learned quickly that the teaching assistants (TA's) that I was working with were all going to the Stanford University Medical Center, where somebody had given the hospital a bunch of half-inch black-and-white reel-to- reel video rovers (portapaks). And to my amazement, I found that these guys (the TA's) would go there, take it out on the weekend, and run around the Bay Area and for eight dollars for a 30-minute reel of tape, make a movie." Rebo had an epiphany. "Gees, do I want to go to film school, or do I want to do this? And I decided that that freedom was something that I was really interested in."

He came back home to the Jersey Shore and wanted to get involved in the New York City's video scene but found it was difficult "I abandoned going to film school, and came back to New York and decided to look into this, I call it Hippie Video, for lack of anything else. Frankly, it wasn't as easy as I would have thought to figure it out." He continues "I had heard about video groups, People's Video Theater, people like that, Global Village. And honestly, they weren't that open to have people come there. But to their credit, Rudy Stern and John Reilly (of Global Village) had convinced the New School that they would teach video." Stern and Reilly were the Global Village principals and their respective orientations represent a bifurcation that would emerge in early video: art vs documentary. Stern was in the art camp and Reilly a documentarian.

Early video contemporary and Videofreex member, Davidson Gigliotti described the Global Village teaching mission on his Early Video Project web site. "It became one of the more active video teaching organizations in New York that grew out of the collective experience, introducing hundreds of students to the intricacies of shooting and editing videotape" (2000).

It seems Global Village was alone among the early groups to set up formal classes to teach this new kind of video to the general public. Among the "hippie video" collectives, membership and involvement would typically be linked to social / buddy network connections and/or counter-cultural or "downtown" status. Barry Rebo commuting into the city from the Jersey Shore fit neither category. However a member of the public (including Rebo) could register for classes at Global Village as one could for any other course given by the New School. Global Village also had another public or gateway aspect in that—again alone among these early groups—it had institutionalized screenings in its Soho loft complete with regular listings and advertising in local papers with set program times. (In 1971 a video screening and "new music" space called The Kitchen was established by Steina and Woody Vasulka. The Kitchen was only that and not a video making collective per se.)

Like Rebo, Edin Velez's got his first video break at Global Village but unlike Rebo, Velez enjoyed immediate traction. He explains—referring to Rebo—who he knew from that time "He missed the window. It's all about time and place, when Barry arrived, I was no longer there. And I remember actually that at that point the sense of a place like Global Village was 'We've got to grow up.'" Velez believes he arrived there in 1970 (possibly 1969) and his best estimate is that was close to a year before Rebo. By then, if there had been an "all comers welcome" atmosphere, it had had passed.

Of the four, Anton Perich had next to no contact with the video collectives, except for very casual contacts and a screening at The Kitchen. He was deeply entrenched in the legendary Max's Kansas City (back room) scene that was many things but certainly not utopian or collectivist. It would be difficult to characterize the Max's scene in a sentence or two but glamor, irony and fame would be valued over scruffiness, earnestness and social change.

Though he had been working in video a few years, Davidovich got to know the video community best via moving to Soho in 1973, then an artists colony. There he became friendly with artist-neighbors such as Nam June Paik, John Reilly, Doug Davis and Joan Jonas. He did not join or interact that much with any of the video groups. His affinities were with the "high art" world and their practitioners, some of whom did video. Davidovich contrasts them with the original video groups "I was interested in some of the work that people like Bruce Nauman was doing. People like Vito Acconci, Dennis Oppenheim, Willoughby Sharp. So it was a different, completely different group. Conceptual people (rather) than like a group like the Videofreex."

He further draws out the distinction "Because at that time, anybody who had a camera and shoot is a video artist. It was not much discrimination because (there were) very, very few people who were crazy enough to have video. So if you have a show, you will have all these people in the show, that they were documentarians, they were people who were "high" and doing video and people who were doing conceptual. They were people who were very good, people who were very bad, people who knew nothing about video. It's all kinds of things were all together."

The Fluid Period

The word that Velez uses to describe this heterogeneous early video period (and activities) is "fluid." This phase would not last more than a few years before the shifting considerations of career, outlets and funding opportunities caused people and groups to specialize and migrate into niches.

According to Velez "People's Video Theater was very much social issue oriented, but the rest of the groups were much more fluid, like Global Village. We would show like an Abbie Hoffman interview, but then we would follow that with some rock and roll. Erotica was big, because nobody could shoot it before." He describes a typical multi-monitor "mixed bag" screening at Global Village in more detail "And we had different combinations of the monitors. And we had three machines playing back. And it was a real mash-up of the Doors playing on, I think Dick Cavett, original footage from Woodstock and a Jim Fouratt (Yippie & gay activist) interview."

Along with this early "fluid" mingling of styles, there was a healthy degree of mixing and fraternity between the groups. Such a spirit is never seamless and Velez remembers tense, competitive relations between Global Village and Videofreex from early on. (He could not remember why.) One place where the early video community really came together was the loft of a European couple deeply involved in early video, Steina and Woody Vasulka. With help from others, they later started The Kitchen in 1971. Originally that venue was geared to showing new video work. (Having gone though various incarnations, The Kitchen endures to this day in west Chelsea.)

Velez describes their loft this way "But going back to the fluidity, a lot of the times I used to visit Woody and Steina, this was actually pre-Kitchen. Their loft on 14th Street was a salon, you know, and you pretty much could go there practically anytime, and they'd be there. And every time you went there, they'd be trying out some new experiment. And, I would just sort of soak it up and then come back, and tell John and Rudi (at Global Village), 'Hey, you know, look what I saw at Woody and Steina's and we'd go 'Oh yeah, let's make some sort of video.' So it was so fluid that it was amazing, that it didn't matter what you did, because we were all sort of experimenting, and sharing, you know, like 'Look, I learned that if you do this'—technical and aesthetic—there was some real openness into everybody sharing and it was a true community, in terms that, people would visit each other."

The Kitchen provided Rebo with a way to further engage the early video community. His description also speaks to how video was situated in a broader downtown arts context. "I also had befriended the original people in The Kitchen when it was at the Broadway Central Hotel that (later) collapsed. And I ended up there in my quest for making a connection, when they were actually building The Kitchen (space). It was a Woody and Steina Vasulka, and it was the Kitchen because it was literally where the kitchen had been in the Broadway Central Hotel and then that became a performing arts center. (Mercer Arts Center) And that was where the (New York) Dolls played, and that was where some good theater was going on. And so I kind of ended up helping them build it. But I was a kid from the New Jersey Shore, and I would be here like it's a single-room occupancy hotel, and you hear gunshots and people yelling and saying, 'What the f**k is going on out there?!' So it was like another kind of introduction to New York."

Funding, Mission and Outlets

Ironically something that helped early video grow in New York also led to a great deal of tension in the community. Intense competition over limited funding led to fractures in the scene. If any one institution nourished early video, especially "video art" it was the New York State Council on the Arts (NYSCA). Velez remembers a meeting where things came to a head. "And the funding was what destroyed the community, in my eyes. I think it was the New York State Council on the Arts was going to actually fund video. And I remember going to a meeting at People's Video Theater, at their loft, where the majority of the makers were there, to discuss this. It was very acrimonious. Because everybody wanted a slice of the pie, and some people wanted a bigger slice of the pie and a lot of arguments were ensuing."

Arts funding brings to the fore issues of audience and mission. One attitude common to at least three of this project's participants is a distinct disinterest in the gallery or museum as a video venue. Rebo always saw himself squarely in the documentary tradition, so exhibiting in a art environment was not a good fit. In the case of Davidovich, an artist with a long history of (video) art exhibits, such venues were ultimately less than ideal. He believes that video is really television by another name and is best experienced in the home. "(To) put a television in a museum didn't interest me because it becomes another element of fine arts. What is unique about television is that it can go directly at home." Given his conceptual art leanings this might seem incongruous but Davidovich embodies that tradition and a pop or populist streak. He described his ambitions for a later cable "art" program "I wanted to do a program like The Ernie Kovacs Show."

Perich started as a painter and film-maker in the European New Wave mold, so he clearly had an art background yet expressed his reservations about art exhibition of video this way "Video artists (were) showing their works in galleries, I felt like gallery was not appropriate. You could not make revolution in gallery. Because portapak was kind of a revolutionary thing."

Both Perich and Davidovich found their video outlet of choice on Public Access in New York City (specifically Manhattan). Starting in 1972 Perich started making short improvised video "movies" with members of the extended Warhol circle. Glenn O'Brien onetime publisher of Warhol's Interview Magazine described the program this way "Anton Perich Presents, an anarchic public access soap opera that featured many of the personalities who haunted Max’s (Kansas City) back room—including Taylor Mead, the Warhol superstar. It was the first underground television show, and the wildest thing ever on the tube anywhere" (2011). Because Public Access afforded Perich this freedom "I never showed in galleries because they were like safe places. You could not make any statement by playing a video in a gallery."

Perich's mission was iconoclastic and almost feral. He observed that television in the early 70's was so clean and perfect, he sought out and developed material that was raunchy and campy. The radical intentions extended beyond subject matter, he wanted the form and style of his videos to upset. He also reveled in low-fidelity. Though his prime years of making these programs pre-dated "punk" – his agenda sounds similar.

Perich "The way I used my camera, I was rebellious, my camera is really crazy. It was fine when Warhol's camera was great. The camera never moved, Warhol's camera was like a brick. My reaction to that was the my camera was like a pencil. Because pencil is so small and light, like new camera is so small and light like a pencil. You can really shift, your eyes are fast with a camera it's fast like your eyes. So in all my movies the camera a is really jerky and antisocial, it makes it difficult to watch. I was looking for the most difficult thing, what is most offensive. I can make somebody watching it go through some pain. I just felt like television was behind its time. It was such Puritan medium. It had to be attacked."

"Anton Perich Presents" premiered on Manhattan Cable Television (Public Access) in January 1973. The half hour improvised "movie" entitled "Mr. Fixit" ends in borderline Xrated activity. The plot involving three amateur actors (Susan Blond, Danny Fields as the couple and Sami Melange as the repairman) portrays complaining, neurotic New Yorkers who require an emergency television repairman. During the initial cablecast the surprised Manhattan Cable transmission person wound up censoring the video in real time. The Village Voice devoted a half page article to the debut, written by early video author and producer Richard Robinson. The article ends this way "Anton Perich's tapes were certainly a marvelous clash of the medium and the message. Is cable going to succumb to middle class values for middle class viewers or is Public Access television going to be just that – if you have something to say, no matter how bizarre, you can say it. Perich has raised this question and if this TV event is pursued to it's logical conclusion we have all the makings of a landmark case which would make "Deep Throat" look small time" (1973, p.33). Though Perich did hit some censorship walls, the FCC rules that govern public access demand that the cable operators not control or restrict content except in those instances involving material that "cable operator reasonably believes contains obscenity." (FCC web site 2016) Which meant that whole programs were hardly ever banned outright. Producers prone to violating content restrictions might have their shows reviewed in advance and sent back to them for editing.

Most all of Davidovich's public access involvement plays out in the mid-to-late 70s and early 80s after the "early video" period. But his preferences were established and his course was set in these early years. Though Perich and Davidovich aimed towards ambitious and radical use of public access, in another sense they targeted a middle ground compared to many of their early video peers. The apparent contradiction can be explained this way, most of their peers either operated within the system of tapes / installations being exhibited in an art niche or they aimed for the largest audience of them all, broadcast television. Many individuals aimed for both outlets. Conversely Perich and Davidovich found the art confines too narrow and regarded the broadcast world as too orthodox and hidebound.

Broadcast Television

In 1972 a new technology enabled the broadcast option for portable half inch video recordings. That development was the standalone digital Time Base Corrector (TBC). That unit started to become widespread two years later. "In February 1974, Consolidated Video Systems announced a new CVS 504 signal digital video corrector to bring nearly all helicalscan color signals up to broadcast color standards" (Abramson, 2003, p.153). The broadcast television technical specification requires a extremely precise or stable time base that the half inch video recorders could not deliver. However the new TBC technology could correct most such tapes and make them broadcast-able. That plus the gradual introduction of affordable color capable equipment made broadcast TV a potential outlet, at least in theory. The group that proved this was possible was Top Value Television better known as TVTV. Its core was comprised of members from Raindance and Videofreex (also Ant Farm from the San Francisco). Their broadcast debut was "Four More Years" about the 1972 Republican National Convention. Many early video peers found the prospect of a broadcast outlet exciting and liberating, but one could also say that it ended an age of innocence, of "video for it's own sake" that was unconventional, personal and experimental.

Edin Velez "I think the most important development was the time base corrector, that was it. Because that makes it broadcast-able. Well, and as with everything, the double-edged sword. Because before, we knew the work would never be on TV, you know? But once the time base corrector had come in, so I think the mentality changed from 'We can do anything we want, we're free, we'll have our own weird cable shows' to 'I could probably make a living off of this, you know, maybe there's a place for me in broadcast television after all.' And to you know, 'Well maybe if I tone down this, or what quirky thing can be shot that will still play?' Whereas before nobody cared, you know? It was truly free, and then it was like, and artists are infamous for self-censorship and a large percentage of those who claim they don't selfcensor are either lying or in denial"

One important broadcast outlet for early 70s independent video makers was WNET's TV Lab (originally 1972-74). It branched out later to include documentaries but started with artists "(the) first year initiates artist-in-residence program with Shirley Clarke, Douglas Davis, Ed Emshwiller, Nam June Paik" (London, 1985, p.254). Though Davidovich applauded the work TV Lab fostered and broadcast, he ultimately takes a dim view "TV Lab was not a factor in television in those days and never became a factor in any history of television." He much preferred the freedom of cable television "ones that could have an impact, it has to be completely alternative to broadcast, not played by the rules, we should use our own rules, this is why we are revolutionaries, anarchists, artists and all these, to our own rules and embrace this opportunity to create the rules of engagement." He found this freedom in his several cable "art" series.

Video Preservation

When it came to the transfers for video migration from obsolete formats, artists and independents had few affordable options in the 70s and 80s. Transfer time at video facilities with high-fidelity broadcast quality videotape recorders was very expensive. Even if one could afford to transfer or "bump-up" lower formats to 2" or 1" videotape for the sake of archiving, those resulting tapes would be very expensive to use as dubbing masters. This situation did not substantially change in New York until the advent of The Standby Program in 1983, that gave artists access to "dark time" at facilities at discounted prices. (Guerrasio, 2003).

Conversely a typical and affordable migration solution for independents was to use each new (relatively) improved low-end format as it became available. The first was U-matic, the second major breakthrough was DV. (In between were the Super-VHS, Video8 and Hi8 formats but compared to the later 1995 DV format, they did not enjoy widespread acceptance.) Davidovich "I needed to update the format, so I have the 1/2", when they started U-matic, I have to transfer everything from 1/2" to U-matic."

Though not a vast improvement over 1/2", the fidelity of dubbing to this second generation on U-matic was less degraded than dubbing to 1/2". And by virtue of being newer and more universal in the marketplace, U-matic was more useful as format for a dubbing master or distribution copy. Until Davidovich's collection was acquired by NYU's Fales Library, he was forced to do what many other early video people did: transfer 1/2" to U-matic which would become the de facto dubbing master. Then later transfer that same U-matic that to DV (because by the mid-90s working 1/2" open reel decks were rare). This would be down two generations from the original but this path or solution was very common. Edin Velez did exactly the same thing. "I went to 3/4, which I thought 3/4 was a lot better. And so basically, I migrated stuff to U-matic, and then I migrated to MiniDV, and so I ended up with over 600 hours of-- and that was culling, 600 hours of MiniDV."

Ultimately Davidovich's body of video work received proper preservation treatment courtesy of the NYU Fales Library. (In 2006 the library acquired his collection, papers, etc.) In speaking with the Fales' Media Archivist Brent W. Phillips, he described the transfer effort subsidized by the National Endowment for the Arts via a grant made in order to digitize seventy five of Davidovich's videos. (personal communication, January 13, 2016). The actual work was done by the Bay Area Video Coalition (BAVC). The transfers were done to Digital Betacam. Phillips indicated this was the consensus choice for preservation at the time, as a file based option hinged on then expensive server storage which did not seem practical. At some point in the future uncompressed 10-bit YUV files were struck from the Digital Betacams. Electronic Arts Intermix distributes Davidovich's videos and Phillips says they acquired a Digital Betacam clone made from the Fales master to use for their dubbing needs.

Anton Perich's preservation efforts were unique within this group of four. In the mid-nineties he learned of an offer by Sony Corporation to transfer Sony 1/2" tapes free of charge. According to Perich this offer was extended to the public and did not require any special credentials. He states "I called Sony and I told them what I had and they said 'Send it to us, we'll do it.' So I first sent first an experimental package to try it, they sent it back to me and it looked fine." Based on that test, he had the confidence to send Sony his entire 1/2" collection to be transferred to Hi8 (he estimated it to be 200 1/2" tapes). It's not clear what the options were for the target format at that time. Original Videofreex member Davidson Gigliotti also took Sony up on the free offer. In his case the transfers were made to VHS. (personal communication, December 14, 2015).

This free Sony transfer program seems worthy of further study both for its role in preserving specific tapes and more generally the idea that a company would act as a guarantor in the migration from its obsolete legacy format. But this might prove difficult to document. Contact was established with the person who ran that program in the 90s, Steven Tice (Senior Manager of Media Services - Americas Zone) now at Sony's Laredo, Texas location. (Where the service of transferring from 1/2" is still provided for a fee.) He doesn't recall a blanket offer of free transfer services, however during the 90s he says he had a much larger staff, then located at Sony's Dothan, Alabama media manufacturing facility (personal communication January 21, 2016).

When Perich was asked about whether he was satisfied with the quality of the Sony transfer to Hi8 he said "Image I feel is, if it was good enough for Sony 1/2" it's good enough for Hi8." Which is to say the low quality of the original 1/2" doesn't require a high-fidelity target format to properly capture or represent it, in his opinion. In a professional preservation context this would be heresy but for independents with low budgets, the migration priorities and agenda take on a "triage" aspect. Simply put, 10-bit uncompressed may be expensive overkill. Perich considered the subject of retransfer somewhat moot since during shipping virtually all the adhesive labels on the 1/2" tapes came off, rendering them unidentifiable without a playback machine.

On a personal level, Barry Rebo's near singular video pursuit in the 70s was documenting the career of his teenage friend Bruce Springsteen. First shooting live shows on 1/2", then later as Springsteen started to spend more time in the studio, shooting there on U-matic and using low-light black & white cameras. Though all the shooting was done with the future star's permission, there was nothing put in writing which destined the tapes to a kind of commercial limbo for decades. In the 80's and 90's Rebo created one of the first studios/production companies that specialized in (first generation) High Definition video. At his west Chelsea location he had a garage for the mobile unit with a safe-vault where he kept these old videotapes along with his video cameras. Rebo "Oh, sat in a vault for 30 years. And that all went into a vault that I kept, and in terms of preservation, I probably did a terrible job! You know, because for a long time it was, I… I bought a safe. And it was in the garage on 25th Street forever, Now most of it (the safe) was for cameras, but in it I had shelves of this stuff. It ended up being this combination of 1/2" black-and-white reel-to-reel stuff; three-quarter-inch stuff, which was probably the majority of it."

By the late 80s Rebo became concerned about the condition of the tapes he knew to be potentially valuable. He reached out to the principal of a facility that worked with legacy video formats (Vidipax) to check them, in order to answer his question "Am I gonna end up with a bunch of dust, or what am I doing here?" After establishing that these tapes were in a decent condition, he could then conduct discussions with Springsteen's management. Though Rebo was confident of the collection's integrity, Springsteen management required a review of samples. "I ended up making the deal to be able to sell the archive to Bruce, they wanted proof of that it wasn't boxes of dust. So I went with a fellow, who's Bruce's main video guy and I packed up all these boxes, I said, 'here's everything,' you know, (and Rebo said) 'Pick random samples of your own volition. I would suggest half-inch, three-quarter inch and one- inch.' And maybe, I don't know, two/three dozen samples. And we went to some place in Queens, and they put them up on respective machines and they played."

On the topic of preservation and the migration of videotapes over time, the most revealing conversation was with Edin Velez. He recalls a stark and negative reaction to his earliest exposure to the principles of video preservation. This was most likely a talk given by Barbara London of the Museum of Modern Art in 1991. (Cited by Boyle, 1993). He indicates that his skepticism and antipathy to this message was shared by others. Because of this and the possibly dire implications it might have, this part of the interview will be given additional space and consideration here, at the end of this paper. (Quotation marks are dispensed with in this Q&A transcription format.)

Velez) The idea of archiving seemed ridiculous and the idea of proper storage was more ridiculous.

Q) That wasn't just you, other people felt the same way?

Oh Absolutely nobody cared!

Q) You mentioned Barbara London (evangelizing about this) and it was lost on people, this would have been the 80's, her first talking about this?

Probably.

Q) Why the negative reaction?

It's almost like Climate Change, well that's your theory… we hadn't had the problems yet. I remember basically just making sure that open reels were wound for a even tape pack and stored vertically like a book, and I felt if you did that they would last forever. And so you know, 'so what is she talking about?' And then when we were moving to U-matics… and then very few people were even going back to their open reel tapes.

Q) People were not going back because they had moved on with there own work and those early tapes were not an important part of their body of work?

Yes and in my case theory were not even back & white, they were grey & white, there were no true blacks there. Very low resolution, etc. so we had moved on. It was like, 'yeah we did that then' but most people were not even showing that stuff. So there was very little interest in preserving what we didn't care that much for and we felt would last forever. It was only when in my case I need to look at some tape, it might have been family stuff. The tape was starting to glue together, you know?

Q) Ah, stick as you played it?

Edin: Yeah.

Q) Get stuck?

Edin: Yeah, you'd (the vtr) just go "eeee - screams" and just stop. Yeah, and that's when 'Uhoh, this is--' and that's when you know, we started researching and there were people doing the blade thing, where they had a blade that they would install, that would theoretically scrape the gunk off the videotape, which seemed to me a kind of very dangerous move. I can't remember who was doing that, but it was publicized-- not publicized, no but people were talking 'This is one of the ways you do it, you can run it through basically some gadget that has a blade set up and the blade will kind of get rid of the top gunk, on the video.'

Preservation Outcomes

Each participant in this study (to date) had a different preservation outcome. In the case of two (Davidovich and Rebo) an institution or a business interest had reason to preserve their early work. Those entities had the resources to do a top tier professional job with a high degree of quality assurance. In the case of Perich, he was able to have most of his work transferred by Sony. Some of his early video "movies" that were transferred this way have an intermittent brightness/contrast problem that several people experienced in early video transfers suspect may have been induced by the particular tbc processing. Sadly it is something of a moot point as (for reasons given earlier) subsequent retransfers do not seem possible.

Velez had the skills and resources to do format migrations for himself over the course of forty plus years. However he did not have ready access to broadcast videotape formats, so had to work with what used to be called "industrial" formats then later "prosumer." This resulted in incremental migrations where generational loss was accumulated with each transfer. This situation was common for early video independents who "made do" with what they had access to. His resulting format path for camera original material was open reel 1/2" to U-matic to miniDV to file based video. (Edited masters also went to BetaSP and DVcam.) Rarely if ever were his original 1/2" tapes transferred to a directly a digital format. Davidovich did much the same thing but, courtesy of the Fales Library efforts, was able to ultimately avoid generation loss because the library had the ability to go back to originals for digitization after the collection was acquired in 2006.

It is hoped that in a follow-up-up paper of greater scope, there will be both more exposition and more conclusions drawn. The area of Public Access (PA) cable television needs more introduction. A colleague from 70s Manhattan Cable is Steve Lawrence who was Public Access Coordinator from 1972 to 1974, then promoted to Director of Community Production Services said about PA “It was, in fact, quite revolutionary, and until the Internet came along there wasn’t another alternative public media platform for artists, activists and documentarians." (personal communication, January 24, 2016).

The main goal of a follow-up-up paper would be to determine what kind of connections or through line there might be from the early 70s video movement to the YouTube present.

References

Abramson, A. (2003). The history of television, 1942 to 2000 (Vol. 2). McFarland.

Boyle, D. (1992). From Portapak to camcorder: A brief history of guerrilla television. Journal of Film and Video p.68.

Boyle, D. (1993). Video preservation: securing the future of the past. Media Alliance.

Boyle, D. (1997). Subject to change: Guerrilla television revisited. Oxford University Press.

Federal Communications Commission. (2016) Public, Educational, and Governmental Access Channels ("PEG Channels"). Retrieved from https://www.fcc.gov/media/public-educational-and-governmental-access-channels-pegchannels

Gigliotti, D. (2000). The Annotated Video Exhibition List (1963-1975). The Early Video Project. Retrieved from http://davidsonsfiles.org/Exhibitions(1963-1975).html

Guerrasio, J. (2003). The Standby Program. The Independent. Retrieved from http://independent-magazine.org/2003/11/standby-program-197/

London, B. (1985). Video: A Selected Chronology, 1963-1983. Art Journal, 45(3), 249-262.

O’Brien, G. (Spring/Summer 2011). How I became a TV star. 10 Magazine. Retrieved from http://www.10magazine.com/news/glenn-obrien-how-i-became-a-tv-star

O'Connor, J. (1983). TV view; Video artists still seek a showcase for their works. The New York Times. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/1983/06/19/arts/tv-view-video-artists-still-seek-a-showcase-for-theirworks.html

Robinson, R. (1973, February 8). Unusual airings: 1984 and cable. Village Voice, p.33

Other links of biographical relevance or interest.

Guide to the Jaime Davidovich Collection 1953-2000. NYU Fales Library http://dlib.nyu.edu/findingaids/html/fales/davidovich/bioghist.html

Barry Rebo, Managing Director of DirectCinema (North America)

Ymagis Group launches North American content-delivery service http://www.filmjournal.com/news/ymagis-group-launches-north-american-content-deliveryservice

Anton Perich on YouTube https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCXnTeNm40LHOY6EJYnQjiNA

Edin Velez - Biography (Electronic Arts Intermix) http://www.eai.org/artistBio.htm?id=462

Summary

Drawing on interviews made in the fall of 2015 with Barry Rebo, Anton Perich, Jaime Davidovich and Edin Velez, the paper adds to the history of New York's early-1970s Portapak era the practitioners who worked outside, or at the edge of, the founding video collectives. It follows their dealings with those groups, their funding, public access cable and broadcast television as outlets for their work, and what became of their early tapes.

Linked source ↗

Cite this record

Dougherty, Paul. Expanding the History of Early Video in New York City. Paper for Introduction to Moving Image Archiving and Preservation, Professor Howard Besser, New York University, Fall 2015. January 27, 2016. pp. 27.

Download RIS citation

If unchecked, this will appear as a public note on the site once an editor has reviewed it.

Changes will be reviewed and integrated as time permits. For major changes, feel free to email support@experimentaltvcenter.org.

Last modified 20 November 2026